WW 44: Battlestar Galactica

[Lewwyn]

So:

The player with most lynch votes at the end of the day is lynched and eliminated from the game. Tiebreaks: There is a tiebreaking mechanism that exists, and makes sense to the GM.

What is that tiebreak mechanism?

You don't get to know.

Ominous.

[Gazglum]

Winston on reread is fine (and less talkative than others due to health so harder to pinpoint scummy/towny posts).
Jabbz less so, but is getting better after a rough start, with good posts against Dp. I had a good feeling on Novice and Lewwyn, so I'm at a dead end. For the record I'm inclined to lynch Dp and if not him then one of Jabbz or Gaz (in that order).

I'm not talkign about you voting me, if thats what you mean Adrien. I mean this post from yesterday. You'd already started downgrading me to misguided town at this point, you say Jabbz is getting better, so you're really only left with DP as someone you've stuck to calling scum all day. But your actual vote on him was for bad logic, and you've struggled to follow that up with a more significant case.

[Jabbz]

Individually I can take them as mistakes, a fervent townie leaping at all possible scum tells. Taken as a whole whoever, the repetitive nature of his posts making the same kind of mistake and being corrected by others, smells different. I'm not sure he is scum, but he seems scummier than anyone else on my list.

I'm not ruling this out, but I'd need more before i voted him. And DP is voting Adrien, my preferred suspect, so at the moment I am hoping that he is locked in on a wolf.

Unfortunately I'm at that place that happens sometimes in WW. Your top scum lean is only slight, but since you have no one else that looks worse, you run with it and hope for the best. I am pretty much null on AdrienIer, so I don't feel comfortable jumping in on him. If someone wants to jump on Dp101, I wouldn't cry. If that happens and I'm wrong, I'll gladly cop to it and deal with it tomorrow, but to be honest, with 14m remaining, I am pretty sure it's going to be Adrien, and we use the info from there, town or scum, to give us a more productive tomorrow.

[AdrienIer]

Something that I'm trying to keep in mind is that with 7 players the dynamics are different. Our cop is probably our best asset so the main priority is not to get him killed, but maybe the scum team will want to try something new (with a possible lylo on D2)

Adrien, what did you mean by this? What was the point of bringing it up, how do you want us to play differently? This post felt like it might be you hinting towards a claim, but then you suggested that your are vanilla town, so then this feels more like just trying to change the subject.

It's my right to share my thoughts even when they aren't particularly linked to the subject at hand or when I don't know for sure what I want to do about the thought

[Qgqqqqq]

So:

The player with most lynch votes at the end of the day is lynched and eliminated from the game. Tiebreaks: There is a tiebreaking mechanism that exists, and makes sense to the GM.

What is that tiebreak mechanism?

You don't get to know.

Ominous.

I will clarify that only one player dies, and that player will be one of the two(+) who are tied.

[AdrienIer]

Winston on reread is fine (and less talkative than others due to health so harder to pinpoint scummy/towny posts).
Jabbz less so, but is getting better after a rough start, with good posts against Dp. I had a good feeling on Novice and Lewwyn, so I'm at a dead end. For the record I'm inclined to lynch Dp and if not him then one of Jabbz or Gaz (in that order).

I'm not talkign about you voting me, if thats what you mean Adrien. I mean this post from yesterday. You'd already started downgrading me to misguided town at this point, you say Jabbz is getting better, so you're really only left with DP as someone you've stuck to calling scum all day. But your actual vote on him was for bad logic, and you've struggled to follow that up with a more significant case.

Perhaps you've missed it (even though I thought it was clear) but my reread didn't make me suspect anyone more than Dp. Without any other lead I'm kind of stuck with a meh vote on Dp

[Lewwyn]

Something that I'm trying to keep in mind is that with 7 players the dynamics are different. Our cop is probably our best asset so the main priority is not to get him killed, but maybe the scum team will want to try something new (with a possible lylo on D2)

Adrien, what did you mean by this? What was the point of bringing it up, how do you want us to play differently? This post felt like it might be you hinting towards a claim, but then you suggested that your are vanilla town, so then this feels more like just trying to change the subject.

It's my right to share my thoughts even when they aren't particularly linked to the subject at hand or when I don't know for sure what I want to do about the thought

I love this so much.

[Gazglum]

Me too. You may die, Adrien, but you will die free.

[AdrienIer]

Yeah I guess ?

[AdrienIer]

*yay