One Night Ultimate Werewolf #4

[Tarkeel]

I see we cross-posted Rowain. I want to state the other part of my swap when that party claims a role, otherwise poor Serdoa is likely to never know what he ended up with.

[Rowain]

@tarkeel none of the claims/hypothetical claims have targeted you with a role-switch. So you are still troublemaker if you were it at start. Please tell whom you switched.

[Tarkeel]

It is one of Cyneheard, Thrawn or GES, neither of which have made any meaningful claims on their role. I don't want to give them an 'out' just yet as it's starting to become obvious there are probaly two (or more) wolves in that pack.

I'm starting to think that the reserve started with Mason, Werewolf and Tanner, which should leave Werewolf, Mystic Wolf, Seer and Witch as unclaimed. I think CMF's witch claim is the more likely.

[Tarkeel]

Also, for what it's worth, given my understanding of the information available to you Rowain, I fully support your lynching of Cyneheard. I promise to make a statement if he was swapped with Serdoa in good time before deadline so we lynch the right wolf.

[Rowain]

@tarkeel the 2nd mason was on a player. please trust me here.

[Rowain]

@thrawn you claimed to have information. care to tell it?

[Tarkeel]

Strange that the other Mason hasn't claimed yet. They might be worried that they no longer are the Mason and sow distrust on you. If they were the player targeted by my swap, they would actually be a Mason again. (Serdoa robbed Mason from Rowain; I then swapped that Mason to REDACTED). They might also be afraid that the witch slapped them with a new role. Given that you're willing to lynch Cyneheard I'd guess that the other Mason is either GES or Thrawn. The only credible claim of witchery so far is CMF claiming to bewitch Thrawn with Tanner, in which case he would want to be lynched and putting him in a very awkward situation.

[Tarkeel]

Another crosspost. How fun it would be if I swapped you with Serdoa, and that was actually one of the options I was entertaining... But no, I did not swap you, and I totally understand why you would hold back that information. It also makes it likely that Chevalier Mal Fet is either a Seer or a wolf.

[Tarkeel]

As I see it these are our options:

A) Thrawn and me are both telling the truth, and whomever I swapped with is a safe lynch.
B) Thrawn is lying (because he's a wolf) but I am telling the truth, and whomever I swapped with is a sure mis-lynch.
C) I am lying and Thrawn is telling the truth, in which case I don't know what I'm trying to achieve here.
D) We're both lying and it's all a dream.

Option A sounds plausible to me. Should I reveal whom the target is?

[Rowain]

Well, it's annoying but it's becoming a mess so I'll take my chances that you swapped someone else.

I'm the witch and gave wolf to Serdoa. Now tell me you didn't swap me with Serdoa!!

Witch card did you chose?