[Game Thread] WW49: Wizards and Werewolves

[AdrienIer]

Yes I didn't like the situation where if he was here he would change his vote and avoid death. If it had been less tight between him and the other option I wouldn't have said anything about his absence

[novice]

That bomb looks like a dangerous item. Probably best to give it to the person we’re lynching tomorrow. Pindicator

[AdrienIer]

About this "don't vote Gaz if he's not here" thing, if you think I was protecting my scumbuddy Gazglum by bussing my scumbuddy WK (only reason scum-me would do that) then giving me the sphere ends the problem : either I'm town and it's all good or I'm scum and tomorrow night when I use it I'll die and there will be one less scum alive.

[Serdoa]

Adrien, I don't know what to think about you, but yes, I thought about if wolves bussed one of theirs. I don't like that idea either though I pondered it. But I think more because I hate being wrong and while I had WK rather down my list, he was not close to being a top candidate for my lynch today. Of course, maybe I was right on Gaz as well?

Anyhow, if you want it Adrien
I wouldn't have anyone else I'd rather give it too either. Not because I like you as choice but I like none of the others any more.

[pindicator]

I was going to propose giving it to you, novice. If you give it to me there's a good chance it never gets used.

[Rowain]

@novice and pindicator what speaks against giving it Adrien?

[Rowain]

I don't like this Gazglum lynch where he's not even here to vote for his survival (which he'd get by voting WK currently, or SD if I were to move).

This is what I am referring to Rowain. If you thought that was my logic, I'm sorry to tell you it was Adriens.

I know that - but you made the leap that we never lynch Gazglum because of that - which given that we (including ADrien) just lynched WK who has the same timezone-problems like Gaz shows not to be true.

[pindicator]

I'm not against Adrien.  But like last night I think we need a strong 2nd place as well, which should also go to a WK voter.  I personally give town leans to a lot of people who voted SK.  Although I can't dismiss perhaps scum-Novice calculated that getting town cred was worth giving up a 50/50 on saving his buddy.  Actually, I'd take the item but I'm very doubtful to ever use it even if I am still around.  Though I'm not sure what more I can do to prove my towniness than pushing a wolf and getting him lynched like I did today.  For that reason and for "cleric-sounds-healy" meta reasons I think there's a possibility that I'm night killed tonight.  (Also, if I'm not tomorrow's lynch that's when I usually end up dead too )

[pindicator]

Actually, I think I like Rowain over novice

[Serdoa]

Um, no, I made no leap.

The statement is

"I don't like this Gazglum lynch where he's not even here to vote for his survival"

Gazglum will never be around at deadline, hence he will never be able to vote for his survival (=vote for who is at the end the second highest vote-holder behind him). Therefore we never lynch him. The same would of course be true for WK.

That WK was lynched just shows that this statement was logically unsound (Adrien didn't like the Gaz lynch, the reason he gave is poorly thought through), not that me progressing it logically to its end is wrong.

God, that will be a fun day tomorrow, if I have to give you logic classes first...