To be honest, I would love it if one of you was the Mafia Day-Vigilante and decided to go out with a bang.
|
WW #43 - The Asha'man
|
(July 13th, 2016, 10:18)Fenn Wrote: I could potentially see a Gaz + novice or Gaz + Lewwyn scum team. Gazglum already knows that I and (in the second scenario) novice are town, and so gives us town reads to get us on-side, allowing a lynch of PGO Rowain to go forward. The problem with that idea is that if Gazglum was Mafia, he'd be much better served by giving a Guilty result on me/novice or (better yet) giving an Innocent result on, like, Dp101 and letting me or novice get lynched. Much safer than giving Innocent results on two players who could be lynched and then gunning for the claimed PGO. A wrong guilty result would make him primary lynch the next day. And who knows if he didn't give a wrong innocent result on you/novice.
My case on Rowain is the same as Day 2:
(July 10th, 2016, 12:56)Gazglum Wrote: Summing up my thoughts on Rowain. None of them is a smoking gun. All of them together, and you can smell the powder. Since then I can add: - Scum have not apparently joined me on his wagon, even though a mislynch is the only way to get rid of him - He called loudly and clearly for people to NOT vote Prometheus near deadline yesterday - In a scum team we know contained a roleblocker, Rowain pushed incredibly hard for a full role-claim - He has backed up Meiz all the way until the last few hours, even while the rest of the town have expressed considerable unease on Meiz - He can't put together a coherent Pairing, even when he is down to a last few possible suspects (July 13th, 2016, 10:22)Gazglum Wrote: Not a strong-man, or someone would be dead Night 1.  are you completly stuipid???? the doctor went to zakalwe who as hider can't be targeted at all. So strongman doesn't do sh** in that case. That there was No Kill besides Adrien can only mean 1 of the following things:. Scum might have targeted AdrienIer. There have been enough reasons pointed why he might have been targetted which you chose to ignore. Scum might have targeted Zakalwe. We have coincitently someone claiming he visited zak (someone who couldn't be sure he wasn't followed or watched when he made his claim) . Scum might have tried Dp101 (if he speaks the truth and you can give me any reason why scum would do that)
The point is, me and novice were plausible lynch targets after Day 2 ended. As Mafia I don't believe he'd want to clear one of us two, let alone both. He could just as easily have claimed to have scanned two of Meiz/Lewwyn/Dp101, or scanned novice but not me - in the case that I'm lynched today and the Mafia make a successful kill tonight (probably on one of the 'confirmed innocents'), D4 opens 2-3 scum-town, and scum!Gaz can claim whatever sort of scan he likes.
(July 13th, 2016, 10:33)Rowain Wrote:(July 13th, 2016, 10:22)Gazglum Wrote: Not a strong-man, or someone would be dead Night 1. I thought strong-man would beat hider, but you are probably right. And yes, obviously I believe that scum targetted zak.
Deadline in ~3h15m. I have a shrink appointment from 11-12, and might not be out at 12, so if someone could please call deadline at 12 and people respect it, that would be great. I'll bring my laptop so I can hotspot and do resolution without having to rely on my shitty phone app.
Tally as of post 826: 2 votes: Rowain (Gazglum, Dp101) 1 votes: Dp101 (novice) 1 votes: Meiz (Lewwyn) 1 votes: Lewwyn (Meiz) 1 votes: novice (Fenn) 1 votes: Prometheus (Rowain) Voting history: (July 13th, 2016, 10:12)Dp101 Wrote:(July 13th, 2016, 09:56)Meiz Wrote: I'm pretty sure the game is no solved Gaz, but that's a problem for another day. DP101 was quick to grasp what enabler is, even that it could disable mafia power (something I hadn't considered at all). Slight suspicion of Lewwyn & DP discussing the claim in quicktopic. Ok, that explains it then. Didn't realized roles were listed there. |
