WW8: Madness in Outer Space (game thread - players only)

[Lewwyn]

Given all this abilities I do wonder about the night-action roleblock claim from Lewwyn. The only night actions we do know about are villager-actions. (Injeras serenade and novices hiding) So what sense does this roleblocking make?

I can roleblock scum from killing. Zak specifically says so in my PM.

[Sareln]

Hmm can't sleep.

I volunteer. If Catwalk wants to kill me in the night by "protecting me" and wounding me, he can then.

Catwalk's ability will only wound you if you're attacked at night. Though that's pretty guaranteed if you can really role-block I think. Now that I think of it though, hasn't Catwalk already claimed to have used his ability on Rowain last night?

How about I kick Catwalk instead? It doesn't much matter who I kick, and that sounds much more satisfying

Kick: <Catwalk>

[uberfish]

it makes a lot of sense to have one SCUM to have wounding power too

...

So the question remains is Sarelns kick a day-action (villager) or a night action. Since nobody has a wounding action left he should prove his kick-abilty by kicking someone.

So that your scum partner, who has a wounding power left, can kill them tonight/tomorrow?

Rowain

[uberfish]

Argh, crossposted with Sareln.

[Lewwyn]

How about I kick Catwalk instead? It doesn't much matter who I kick, and that sounds much more satisfying

Kick: <Catwalk>

Oh yeah, that's satisfying.

So Catwalk's ability only wounds if it actually protects. But Novice's wounded him even THOUGH he protected himself and wasn't targeted. There a disconnect there. Maybe Catwalk's lying to us?

[zakalwe]

- Hey Catwalk?
- Yeah?
- I have a message from your wife, said Sareln, giving Catwalk a vicious kick in the nuts.
- That was uncalled for, groaned Catwalk (whose gait would be unlikely to improve after this), rolling on the floor.
- Technically not.

Catwalk is now wounded. He was kicked by Sareln.

[Lewwyn]

No Vote

It would be too powerful for scum to have the ability to kill wounded people and the day without a lynch. I think its safe to say that Sareln is innocent.

Although... That does mean that scum could be given a heal power to offset the 2 wounding vigilantes.

[zakalwe]

Official Tally - Day 3 - 7 alive - 4 to lynch

2: Rowain (Novice, Uberfish)
1: Lewwyn (Catwalk)

Ineligible: Erebus

Not voting: Rowain, Sareln, Lewwyn, [strike]Erebus[/strike]

Wounded: Catwalk

[Rowain]

It's a day action.

Are you volunteering?

I would have preferred that you kick me Sareln. to stop such idiocity like this:

So that your scum partner, who has a wounding power left, can kill them tonight/tomorrow?

Rowain

@uberfish: And who should that be? Whom do you believe to still have a wounding power left?

From those still living we have only Catwalk and Lewwyn with their power not used. Are you SCUM.

@Lewwyn Nice try to deflect.

[Lewwyn]

Right now I think:

[COLOR="Green"]Innocent:
Lewwyn - As always.
Sareln - reasoning stated above[/COLOR]

[COLOR="Yellow"]Probably Innocent:
Erebus - I actually think that his role would be game breaking as a scum
Novice - I still believe the wound yourself to keep yourself protected thing based on the "wound" being a cold.[/COLOR]

[COLOR="Red"]Possible Scum:
Uberfish - weak ability designed for misdirection rather than action which is more of a scum objective, however he did readily own up to it.
Rowain - Healer, neutral comments, and process of elimination
Catwalk - I think he's lying.[/COLOR]


So... I'm considering voting Catwalk or Rowain.