LURZKERS THREAD (for siege of the dragon)

[Tasunke]

Any scum faction could have lost without a single lynch, but without any scum lynches, the village would have lost. That is, in a way, how it was balanced. But I've commented on the set up much more in the Author's thread which may or may not be linked to at game's end.

[Tasunke]

any dead players wish to discuss set up with me on Skype?

[Lewwyn]

Do not read if you don't want to be spoiled at to who the last hunter and wolf are:

Rowain-hunter
Selrahc-wolf
Serdoa-SK

Slow-martyr
Waterbat-village vig
Matt-fire elemental
azza-airelemental

Everything is easy to figure out at this point. I confirmed Selrahc is last wolf with bigger on gchat.

[Qgqqqqq]

Just FYI

When I stated that hunters would probably be dead tommorow, its not because I believed Selrahc, its because I think he's likely to be targeted.

[novice]

I do think the 3way mason group was a bit much but whats crazy isthey were all silent through the days and ended having to reveal to save themselves.

I know. For the record, I didn't claim to save myself.

[uberfish]

Pretty sure SC's role has to be real and town and we have two masons which leaves 3 out of 4 remaining scum by PoE. of these I see serdoa as the most likely dragon as he's playing like he can't be night killed and dragon pretty much has to be immune. Selrahc fishing for the information on whom Waterbat poisoned is also scummy. Tossup between waterbat and rowain for the last scum slot.

I'll hold further comments about the setup until the end of the game.

[uberfish]

It's probably unwinnable for village but I don't regard this as a legitimate loss.

[zakalwe]

Bigger, no offense intended about your play, but I really don't think your claim would have held up to much scrutiny. I was having some second thoughts after the lynch, not because I regretted lynching Lewwyn, but because I thought you might have been an even better lynch.

On the other hand, it must be damn hard to come up with a good claim for scum, here.

[Lewwyn]

It's probably unwinnable for village but I don't regard this as a legitimate loss.

I agree with this. I think its still fun as a quick game, but it ends up being a lot more luck than skill.

Bigger, no offense intended about your play, but I really don't think your claim would have held up to much scrutiny. I was having some second thoughts after the lynch, not because I regretted lynching Lewwyn, but because I thought you might have been an even better lynch.

On the other hand, it must be damn hard to come up with a good claim for scum, here.

Well, I think I played fairly villagery. I simply became the lynch target by process of elimination. No one really had any case against me. I just wasn't online during the key hours (as usual) in order to claim a "passive ability". I ended up voting for two masons at the end of the days because they kept revealing after I went to bed. Its one of the reasons on Day 2 I kept harping about people have to post. With everyone silent there wasn't as much I could play off.

In the end though me getting lynched was great because I got to kill someone else. And I think that the hunters group that's gotten lynched both days has been mostly luck. Though I did tell Qg he was in trouble in the hunter thread after he posted about the "useless" vote.

[zakalwe]

One stroke of luck for town was that two very prominent mislynch targets rolled mason.

Your play was good, Lewwyn, I only got some vague scum vibes, and like you say, I had to eliminate some options before landing on you. You did get lynched on day 2, though. I am content with that.