BTW tomorrow the requested 3 days of peace for Serdoa are over. So anyone who still thinks he is scummy can do what pleases him. Thanks for honouring my request.
| Poll: How surprised are you to see a poll up again? You do not have permission to vote in this poll. |
|||
| Not very. | 2 | 15.38% | |
| Exceedingly! | 2 | 15.38% | |
| You're a damn commie trying to sabotage the thread again aren't you? | 9 | 69.23% | |
| Total | 13 vote(s) | 100% | |
| * You voted for this item. | [Show Results] |
|
WW 31 Game Thread PARANOIA
|
|
Somebody mention marshmallows?
-- Don’t forget.
Always, somewhere, someone is fighting for you. -- As long as you remember her, you are not alone.
Rowain, for me that reads extremely scummy. I see no reason for a villager to post that.
Apart from that, looking at the actual game and taking into account that Jowy is indeed proven by the results we have to lynch tomorrow one of: - Bob - novice - catwalk - Ichabod - Qgqqqqq And of those imo novice and Ichabods claim are the most unbelievable. I still don't get why someone would not reveal that he is a watcher tbh. Also I expect to be dead tomorrow. Probably for the best, right now I find this game incredibly frustrating... (January 28th, 2014, 09:06)Serdoa Wrote: I still don't get why someone would not reveal that he is a watcher tbh. That is the real question. Usually watcher is townaligned (and tracker scumaligned) so why did the watcher not claim. But we do know that it is (most likely) not Qgqqqqq. OTOH lynching Qg might be the best play so that we finally learn if we had 2 scum up there on D1 or not. Currently there are only 2 Qg voters left alive.
I don't think so novice. Imo the watcher can't have a second power because in that case MJW would have had that power as well. He didn't state anything to that extent and I don't think that he would not have revealed that as it would be an important information.
On that note, while researching for the above I also found that MJW also stated on N3 that he would go for the obvious target, addressed towards the watcher. That does indicate that he did not kill novice but did watch. So I think novices kill is not to be attributed to him either. Of course he could have changed his mind later, but for now I would assume he has not. What of course means that we have 3 kills on N3 unclear. Actually: N1: Ryan, Lewwyn, Old Harry (Gazglum, block Merovech), [zakalwe protected by Rowain] = 3-4 (?) N2: Qgqqqq (Azarius), MJW, 2x Serdoa (Gazglum but protected by Rowain) = 4 N3: novice, zakalwe, MJW, [Serdoa by Azarius, protected by Rowain] = 4 So I guess we can conclude that scum kills are N1: Ryan, Lewwyn N2: MJW, Serdoa N3: novice, zakalwe, MJW I think we knew all that already, but it still means that somewhere another kill was added that was not used N1 and N2. Either that or it was not useable at that stage. Doesn't help us right now unfortunately. (January 28th, 2014, 10:45)Serdoa Wrote: I don't think so novice. Imo the watcher can't have a second power because in that case MJW would have had that power as well.Nope MJW only got powers used against/on him. (January 28th, 2014, 10:45)Serdoa Wrote: On that note, while researching for the above I also found that MJW also stated on N3 that he would go for the obvious target, addressed towards the watcher. That does indicate that he did not kill novice but did watch. a) I doubt he had again a watcher ability (= I'm not sure he keeps all his power over time) b) even if he had both abilities why shouldn't he be able to use both? Still we should not hang ourself on "what scum possible did - or not" but look more towards who is scummy for his play or not. |
