WW 46: Wolves Return to Realms Beyond

[Charriu]

I was able to re-read GKC, which was easier then expected, because he may have a lot of posts, but those are rather short. Note that this is already a tiny negative in my book.

First of all GKC was one of the players, who was defended by a known wolf (#70) early on. I know that doesn't immediately mean anything. It's just a tiny puzzle piece. We also know that there was his rule-break with the edited post on day 1, but that also was a tiny issue. To add a nother small issue is the hiccup with his vote-testing (#113) to which I have to say, you could have just tested that in the Offtopic section of the forum.

Bigger accusations came from dead villagers like Meiz (#575) and I wholeheartedly have to agree, that definitely looks like a defense for Cyneheard - a by now known wolf. In addition to that he this post reads like a deliberate jab at Bob (#267) and in the end he also voted Bob on day 1, which saved Cyneheard. On day 2 he voted nauf, which was a safe null vote.

He also claimed credit for the push on Cyneheard (#432)(#489) although he never actually voted against Cyneheard (His only vote against Cyneheard was a vote that he himself called a test and definitely falls into the early joke-vote phase). He later defended that (#578) claiming that all answers lie in (#255). But I have to say that #255 post is rather weak.

Another tiny issue from night 2, he said he wanted to post something that night, but never followed through with that (#674), which is a disappointment.

Then we have the already mentioned 8 minute posts between (#716 - #718)

All in all that also doesn't look that great for GKC. I'm still very much conflicted with now 3 people being very suspicious, but I will stay on scooter, who looks the worst right now.

[Rowain]

For any villager who is still playing and not only joking around please answer:

Even if we lynch scooter, what then? If he comes up wolf, do we lynch pindicator next anyway? If he comes up village, do we lynch pindicator still?

[scooter]

Arooooooo.





I'm a werewolf. scooter


You'll never take me alive. Vote for me all you want, it won't matter. You've already lost. Stay safe tonight. There are far scarier things out there than me. Shout-out to Brick.

[pindicator]

For any villager who is still playing and not only joking around please answer:

Even if we lynch scooter, what then? If he comes up wolf, do we lynch pindicator next anyway? If he comes up village, do we lynch pindicator still?

Well I was about to ask why you aren't voting for me, but there's a relevant crosspost.

So my shot did get redirected

[pindicator]

No wait, me or scooter jailed + SK still applies

[Rowain]

oh oh that doesn't bode well.

Still scooter I am surprised you moved to a name-calling-outburst as defense.

[Rowain]

Well I was about to ask why you aren't voting for me, but there's a relevant crosspost.

So my shot did get redirected

I explained it when I moved to scooter. Commodore has quoted it already and made fun of it.

Still the question from Serdoa remains (except if you don' t count yourself as villager).

[Commodore]

oh oh that doesn't bode well.

Still scooter I am surprised you moved to a name-calling-outburst as defense.

Come, please, I still want to hear why Scooter is a bad lynch. Just a little more tortured logic, CMF is really wanting the cover.

[Rowain]

Commodore

oh oh that doesn't bode well.

Still scooter I am surprised you moved to a name-calling-outburst as defense.

Come, please, I still want to hear why Scooter is a bad lynch. Just a little more tortured logic, CMF is really wanting the cover.

You could answer the (Serdoa's) questions.

Oh wait I asked villagers to respond so never mind then.

[Chevalier Mal Fet]

I mean if going arooo I'm a werewolf doesn't make me vote scooter I guess nothing will.

For what it's worth, I still don't think the logic is as open and shut as Commodore makes it sound. As I can tell, it runs:

1)One of Pindi and Scooter MUST be lying. (They both might be)
2)Of the two, pindi had good reason to shoot scooter, as the second highest vote getter, but scooter had no good reason to shoot at pindi (more likely he would have shot Lewwyn, I suppose?)
3)Therefore, scooter is almost certainly lying (and pindi is probably lying, too).
4)Therefore, scooter is a wolf.

I guess it hinges on whether or not you think scooter was telling the truth in his pindi target. I...don't have a good read on it. It doesn't seem ironclad, but I guess nothing is.

I also know this vote won't win me town points, but what the hell.