WW26: The Masquerade [Game Thread]

[Doctor Saul]

Maybe she is a vig that only kills wolves? We didn't have any extra villager death except the first night.

Young Will is village by his ability. Or the GM is a bastard
I scanned Hard Nose Harry but got no result

[Know-Nothing Jon]

Or maybe a vigilante that only kills werewolves, not villagers?

Cross-posting, heh.

[Know-Nothing Jon]

Maybe she is a vig that only kills wolves? We didn't have any extra villager death except the first night.

Young Will is village by his ability. Or the GM is a bastard
I scanned Hard Nose Harry but got no result

I love how my "Hard Nose" typo is propagating.

If Agnes could only kill wolves, she should have left some breadcrumbs about who she's tried to kill, because any failed kill would clear a villager. Very powerful role, if it has multiple shots.

I can't imagine the wolves would block you now, when they didn't do so earlier. And our jailer is dead. Maybe your "no result" has to do with Half-Nose Harry's role.

[Know-Nothing Jon]

I think I want to hear a claim from Half-Nose Harry. And from Short Richard too, obviously.

[Know-Nothing Jon]

Villagers:
LE, Young will

high chance of being villagers:
Agnes, KN-Jon, Rose

scummyside/unclear

Dr. Saul, HN-Harry, Sir Percival

Toplynch:

Muriel, Richard

I didn't list Rob on purpose

Why didn't you list Rob in this post, Widow Edith? (Last-minute post on night 3.)

[Doctor Saul]

I wonder if she tried to shoot me. Good thing i am not a wolf!

[Rob The Filch]

I was hoping I'd be dead. But oh well.

After this post yesterday:

BRick being mean enough to make a friendly neighbor be a wolf feels farfetched enough to be ruled out. My first impression was that Saul was obviously a wolf and that I couldn't believe Saul got someone mislynched and got away with it. I've have been getting village reads on him, and have been warming up to the Fool idea...

Definitely getting an uneasy feeling from Muriel's posts. I still can't wrap my head around her argument with Sister Mary.

I was pretty sure Short Richard was a wolf and Muriel was a villager. But in the end Muriel had to be lynched because her play did not deserve to be rewarded. I also believe that the village has a better chance of winning with her dead. Not that I intend to try very hard.

[Doctor Saul]

I still do not like how quiet Short Richard has been so I will stay on him. Harry is another one who has been quiet so I am wondering about my scan. Would an insane random seer have no results too? But I don't like that explanation

[Half-Nose Harry]

I was hoping I'd be dead. But oh well.

After this post yesterday:

BRick being mean enough to make a friendly neighbor be a wolf feels farfetched enough to be ruled out. My first impression was that Saul was obviously a wolf and that I couldn't believe Saul got someone mislynched and got away with it. I've have been getting village reads on him, and have been warming up to the Fool idea...

Definitely getting an uneasy feeling from Muriel's posts. I still can't wrap my head around her argument with Sister Mary.

I was pretty sure Short Richard was a wolf and Muriel was a villager. But in the end Muriel had to be lynched because her play did not deserve to be rewarded. I also believe that the village has a better chance of winning with her dead. Not that I intend to try very hard.

This is just bad. I agree that Muriel's play was pretty terrible, but saying you voted someone you thought was innocent to punish them is awful. With so few lynches left voting someone for a reason other than thinking their scum is just dumb. It's good to finally know where the third kill came from on night one. My take on Agnes's flip is the same as Saul and Jon's, some kind of werewolf only vig, at least the silver part points in that direction. Maybe it was made based on Lewwyn's claimed role from last game, where he said he would only harm undead. This implies that if she targeted someone and they didn't die, they would be a villager, or at least not a werewolf. That seems like a pretty strong role for a not heavy-role game hoiwever so I'm not sure. On the chance that it does work that way I went back and read her posts from day 3 on, since she killed on night 1 she wouldn't have any extra information before that. I didn't find anything that really stuck out as far as her defending anyone, or giving any opinions on someone in a way that would lead me to believe she tried to kill someone and they didn't die.

Saul keeps sounding weird. BRick wouldn't replace someone and not tell us would he? He hardly even seems like the same person that started playing this game.

Jon, I don't know why Saul would get a no result on scanning me. I don't have anything special that would affect his scan. I agree that it makes no sense for him to be roleblocked last night and not before if the wolves do have a roleblocker. Having no result be a possible result of a scan if he is a fool seems harsh even if he is a fool. What do you hope to achieve in asking for claims? I don't think it can hurt anything, but at this point what will it achieve? We're at lylo, so it's not like we have lynches to burn verifying a claim.

[Agnes The Orphan]

[I open the forum]
Hmm why can I now see the lurker thread...oh wait
GG all, its been a pleasue!