Posts: 10,536
Threads: 395
Joined: Aug 2015
PS : Now that I think about it, a system where armor is accurately simulated but armor piercing/illusion/doom are not is probably a bad idea that will inherently cause the wizard with high armor or single figure units to come up on top - which isn't any better than the current "berserkers/figures win" situation. Worse, actually.
"Berserkers win" is a self-removing problem. Once the berserkers do beat another city, the AI's "best race" is no longer barbarian and no more barbarian settlers will be built. (same is true for Gnolls, the other high figure/attack rating race, so the two most likely candidates for creating this problem are contained in most games.)
High armor/single figure units are usually made by better races, that the AI won't "replace", so their overabundance will not be uncontrolled. Which means armor ignoring abilities on the human player's side will be even more powerful than they already are, as enemies vulnerable to these are more likely to develop into the largest threat.
Posts: 5,010
Threads: 17
Joined: Aug 2016
... So, allow the whole system to not work well because the AI might not react well to it? That makes no sense.
If we can fix the combat part, we can figure out a system for overland rating - look at your garrison priorities. They aren't based on the strategic value already.
The overland rating part we can work out.
Do we have space to make these formulas complicated enough that we can keep track of armor and figures?
And YES the defensive and offensive ratings interact. Whenever damage is dealt.
Unit offensive value might be attack*10*modifiers + (figures+1)*3000
Damage formula:
Defender side defensive value = defender hp value (picked out from the last 3 digits of tge defenddr defensive rating) - Attack (picked out from the last 4 digits) *10*figures (which we can pick out based on the first 2 digits, just liked we picked out armor from the first 2 digits) - defender armor rating (which we can pick out from the defensive rating that we're using)*10*modifiers (such as +to defend), minimum zero.
So yes, we can actually make this work in the combat.
But it depends on space.
Then, once we've made it work, we can work out a rating for the AI. (In fact, the ai can just call the combat routine. If it comes close to winning, it knows it can attack. Could even include spells, which is NOT something the AI can do right now when judging ivrrkand strength.)
Overland army graph will be much trickier. I'm confident we cab work something out though. That one has been inaccurate forever, but it only affects very particular rare diplomacy decisions, so we can set it to whatever we need to make the AI effective. All the same info is there as now, so we could even just end up with the sane var as now, although I wouldn't suggest that.
June 5th, 2017, 18:19
(This post was last modified: June 5th, 2017, 19:24 by Nelphine.)
Posts: 5,010
Threads: 17
Joined: Aug 2016
We can also accurately simulate armor piercing, since armor is done during the damage roll. Which means those abilities become accurate modifiers in armor, not arbitrary modifiers on attack strength. Edit: This isn't true. I can't simulate how many things have armor piercing. Either everything does or nothing does, if I wanted to go that route. Oh well.
I'm complrely willing to write out the entire formulas needed, but I need to know space limitations.
June 5th, 2017, 18:27
(This post was last modified: June 5th, 2017, 18:28 by Nelphine.)
Posts: 5,010
Threads: 17
Joined: Aug 2016
Note: my whole point is that I've solved problem zero as you call it.
June 5th, 2017, 18:29
(This post was last modified: June 5th, 2017, 18:36 by zitro1987.)
Posts: 1,341
Threads: 24
Joined: Feb 2012
The basic formulas in many ways fail to properly determine the overall non-skill combat effectiveness of units, resulting in strange determination of wizard army strength, strategic combat results, etc. I assume there's nearly no space to change the structure of the formulas, but I would assume the current numbers could be tweaked.
*I am annihilating a barbarian-oriented wizard that had 3X the overall combat rating than me. Something isn't right here.
Basic Melee formula (there's a place with a 'minus', I propose shifting it to the right:
Current: (Unit melee attack - 2) x unit figures x 20 * (1+.33 (to hit))
Proposal: Unit melee attack x (unit figures +1) X 20 * (1+.33 (to hit))
While the parenthesis serves a purpose to lessen attack rating of weaker melee output in multi-figures, I believe adding unit figures by 1 is more effective at the same thing.
*Why (reason 1)? the fewer the figures, the higher the chance of maximum damage output, simulating more closely this advantage from tactical battle.
*Why (reason 2)? by increasing the attack effectiveness of single-figures (and to a lesser extend 2X figures) vs 6-8 figures, it simulates the tactical battle advantage of high one-figure attacks cracking through enemy armor
*Also, in a sense, helps bring fewer figures to a higher chance of winning. Single figures typically have fewer HP compared to multi-figures
Ranged Combat
Current: (Unit ranged attack -2) x unit figures x 20 * * (1+.33 (to hit))
Proposal: (Unit ranged attack -2) x unit figures x 16 * * (1+.50 (to hit)) - to account for typical range penalty, which struggles against armor
Optional Different Proposal: Unit ranged attack x (unit figures +1) X 20 * (1+.33 or .50 (to hit)) - it is more difficult to cause damage from ranged if range penalties happen. Lower-figure units typically have higher chance of dealing some damage to higher armor units.
Ranged Thrown/Firebreath: Unit melee attack x (unit figures +1) X 12 * (1+.33 (to hit)) - given the shift in parenthesis, you'd have to be careful not to keep it overpowered, thus only a '12' multiplier.
Defensive: Just the basic formula, I think I understand that the math is the 'big picture' of all troops.
Current: Unit health x unit figures x 4 x (unit defense +4) - the current system is not favorable to high armor, considering how useful it is in combat. It also scores too high for clearly vulnerable, but multi-figure units with low armor. For example, werewolves with normal weapons have about half the points of a stone giant.
Proposal: Unit health X unit figures X 5 X (unit defense +3) - while this change is fairly subtle, it can change relative defense rating of an armored single unit vs vulnerable multi-figure by over 20%. This can help bring dragons, archangels, etc to have higher defense ratings vs something easily beatable like a beastman halberdier.
Proposal 2 (may not be possible): unit health X unit figures X 3 X (unit defense + resistance) - you can argue that resistance can really make a difference in battles, sometimes even more so than armor, especially with wizards and certain units. I'm not sure whether replacing an integer with a variable is possible. This proposal also helps bring advanced units up in rating, because they tend to have ridiculous resistance points.
Why we still have problems with this change - usually 1 unit of strength 2X is better than 2 units of strength X. Nevertheless, I hope it's a step in the right direction.
Note: Nelphine and I think alike! (the 'figures +1' idea on attack rating)
Posts: 5,010
Threads: 17
Joined: Aug 2016
heh; although, my plan (I hope) is to actually include armor properly in the formula. Meaning, armor takes place during the damage formula, not something arbitrarily combined with health in nonsensical manners.
I have the exact formulas that will be used, and they do replicate tactical (except for movement). Basically they represent the armies smashing into each other and then randomly attacking whatever is nearby.
Ah crap. I can't actually do armor piercing completely accurately. I can't keep track of how many figures it applies to. On a one on one level I can do it just fine. Ah well. Wish I had several more digits to work with, but, space! So limited.
Posts: 5,010
Threads: 17
Joined: Aug 2016
So, for AI decisions. Since this system actually allows for accurate armor (and inaccurate armor piercing, which is a relatively rare ability anyway) calculations, how does the human make decisions on what to attack?
Please note, since the AI can just compare strategic stacks against each other, individual stacks are already solved. They can still work out a good fight.
But, army graph strength, and diplomacy. That can't be done that way at all. By definition it includes multiple stacks - ALL the stacks.
So how do I decide when to go to war? I go to war when my doomstack is ready; and if my opponent is big enough, I need to have multiple doomstacks, 1 for every.. 6 cities or so. I also need to have 1 strong defensive stack for every 4-9 cities, depending on how long peace has raged.
So when is my doomstack ready? When my best unit can crush my enemies best unit. And my doomstack has at least 6 such units, plus at least 3 other units that are at least 75% the strength of my best unit.
Once I get there, the army graph means nothing; I know my best can beat their best; the only other thing I need to worry about is pure numbers of units. If the enemy can attack with enough stacks, my doomstack can't stop them.
So, I need 6 units that are at least 120% the strength of my enemies best unit. I need at least 3 more units at least 90% the strength of my enemies best unit.
And I need a certain number of units compared to my opponent size, so that I can throw cannon fodder in their way until my real units destroy them. Call it.. 8 units per city I own, plus 2 units per node and tower I control, plus 2 units per city my opponent owns. I have absolutely no idea if that's actually accurate, but it sounds like what I do.
Can the AI remotely work on any system like that? Probably not. That would require working doomstacks. Blech. Not helpful.
Ok, how else do humans decide diplomacy based on military strength? (Note that for my own example, military strength had nothing to do with strategic strength or the army graph. I'm very interested in hearing what other humans consider, to see if any of them could be turned into a working army graph the AI can use.)
Posts: 10,536
Threads: 395
Joined: Aug 2015
If I haven't made myself clear enough :
I'm not going to change the AI in 20 different locations just to make strategic combat work better. And I probably can't even if I wanted, there is no way space allows that in every single location, we can't be that lucky.
So no, you haven't solved problem zero. Problem zero is coming up with a system that does not require AI changes outside of the rating procedure itself.
To put it in perspective, problem zero is coming up with a solution that does not require changing the area marked red, see image below - changing the parts in green is acceptable but space is extremely constrained there so nothing too complicated is possible.
Your suggestion would require changing everything marked red.
Quote:Please note, since the AI can just compare strategic stacks against each other, individual stacks are already solved.
No it can't, if you suggest the AI running a full strategic combat every time they want to compare units and throwing away the result. That would take too much time and it can't be done during normal combat.
Quote:I assume there's nearly no space to change the structure of the formulas, but I would assume the current numbers could be tweaked.
This is a correct assumption. Changing the structure of the formulas is possible but only if the total space used by them remains the same or less.
Melee suggestion : This makes sense, and worth considering. I'll run a calculation to see how it affects ratings. and post the results.
Ranged suggestion : No. Half the ranged units are not affected by ranged penalties (everything with a magical ranged attack), and the type of ranged attack is not known for the procedure.
Thrown : Feels very underrated for such a powerful ability. Sure, it doesn't work for counterattacks, but when the unit is attacking, it's better than a normal attack as it prevents enemy retaliation. I can agree to 30 being too much though, probably 20 is a more fair approximation.
Defense : Resistance is not possible (and wouldn't work well, as it scales differently than armor). Not sure if I like reducing the "+4" - that would make a way too large difference in the health rate of low armor units (at +3, the first armor point is worth 33% extra, the next 25% etc - in other words low armor units such as bowmen would get somewhat underrated.)
June 6th, 2017, 05:37
(This post was last modified: June 6th, 2017, 05:41 by zitro1987.)
Posts: 1,341
Threads: 24
Joined: Feb 2012
(June 6th, 2017, 05:17)Seravy Wrote: Melee suggestion : This makes sense, and worth considering. I'll run a calculation to see how it affects ratings. and post the results.
Ranged suggestion : No. Half the ranged units are not affected by ranged penalties (everything with a magical ranged attack), and the type of ranged attack is not known for the procedure.
Thrown : Feels very underrated for such a powerful ability. Sure, it doesn't work for counterattacks, but when the unit is attacking, it's better than a normal attack as it prevents enemy retaliation. I can agree to 30 being too much though, probably 20 is a more fair approximation.
Defense : Resistance is not possible (and wouldn't work well, as it scales differently than armor). Not sure if I like reducing the "+4" - that would make a way too large difference in the health rate of low armor units (at +3, the first armor point is worth 33% extra, the next 25% etc - in other words low armor units such as bowmen would get somewhat underrated.)
Melee - I'm glad you're willing to consider it, it's the one proposal I feel confident on
Ranged - I see. Nonetheless, maybe we can apply the same formula as melee instead.
Thrown - I see the point and propose 12 -> '15-16' instead, but '20' might be ok, especially since units like sky drakes might need a strategic combat boost.
Defense - This is the trickiest formula, because armor is treated as diminishing returns percentage-wise, when it clearly isn't, leaving high-armor but not super hp units like most very rares and experienced heroes falling behind. The current system is not good, but my proposals were not good either, because of the formula structure.
Posts: 10,536
Threads: 395
Joined: Aug 2015
Current unit ratings :
Code: Trireme (None)
ARATE : 198 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 475 TOTAL = 22 COSTEFF = 1567
Galley (None)
ARATE : 237 RRATE : 138 DRATE : 633 TOTAL = 57 COSTEFF = 2373
Catapult (None)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 257 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 14 COSTEFF = 870
Warship (None)
ARATE : 277 RRATE : 237 DRATE : 891 TOTAL = 111 COSTEFF = 3271
Spearmen (Barbarian)
ARATE : 129 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 1522
Swordsmen (Barbarian)
ARATE : 277 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 166 TOTAL = 11 COSTEFF = 1532
Bowmen (Barbarian)
ARATE : 33 RRATE : 158 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 5 COSTEFF = 751
Cavalry (Barbarian)
ARATE : 396 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 285 TOTAL = 27 COSTEFF = 2821
Shaman (Barbarian)
ARATE : 52 RRATE : 104 DRATE : 110 TOTAL = 4 COSTEFF = 343
Settlers (Barbarian)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Berserkers (Barbarian)
ARATE : 1108 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 498 TOTAL = 134 COSTEFF = 5517
Spearmen (Beastmen)
ARATE : 158 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 9 COSTEFF = 3744
Swordsmen (Beastmen)
ARATE : 237 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 332 TOTAL = 19 COSTEFF = 2622
Halberdiers (Beastmen)
ARATE : 475 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 570 TOTAL = 66 COSTEFF = 4512
Bowmen (Beastmen)
ARATE : 79 RRATE : 158 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 13 COSTEFF = 1872
Priests (Beastmen)
ARATE : 158 RRATE : 237 DRATE : 380 TOTAL = 36 COSTEFF = 1501
Magicians (Beastmen)
ARATE : 52 RRATE : 396 DRATE : 221 TOTAL = 24 COSTEFF = 825
Engineers (Beastmen)
ARATE : 79 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 4 COSTEFF = 624
Settlers (Beastmen)
ARATE : 4 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 396 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 10
Centaurs (Beastmen)
ARATE : 158 RRATE : 237 DRATE : 316 TOTAL = 30 COSTEFF = 2080
Manticores (Beastmen)
ARATE : 576 RRATE : 202 DRATE : 498 TOTAL = 94 COSTEFF = 2421
Minotaurs (Beastmen)
ARATE : 660 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 760 TOTAL = 122 COSTEFF = 2508
Spearmen (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 79 RRATE : 33 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 1101
Swordsmen (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 158 RRATE : 79 DRATE : 166 TOTAL = 9 COSTEFF = 1092
Halberdiers (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 356 RRATE : 158 DRATE : 380 TOTAL = 47 COSTEFF = 2712
Cavalry (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 237 RRATE : 104 DRATE : 285 TOTAL = 23 COSTEFF = 2024
Priests (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 104 RRATE : 396 DRATE : 253 TOTAL = 30 COSTEFF = 1054
Settlers (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Nightblades (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 716 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 570 TOTAL = 99 COSTEFF = 2720
Warlocks (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 21 RRATE : 554 DRATE : 126 TOTAL = 17 COSTEFF = 452
Nightmares (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 396 RRATE : 396 DRATE : 506 TOTAL = 97 COSTEFF = 2003
Spearmen (Draconian)
ARATE : 129 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 142 TOTAL = 4 COSTEFF = 1221
Swordsmen (Draconian)
ARATE : 277 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 190 TOTAL = 12 COSTEFF = 1315
Halberdiers (Draconian)
ARATE : 594 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 427 TOTAL = 61 COSTEFF = 3170
Bowmen (Draconian)
ARATE : 33 RRATE : 158 DRATE : 142 TOTAL = 6 COSTEFF = 678
Shaman (Draconian)
ARATE : 52 RRATE : 104 DRATE : 126 TOTAL = 4 COSTEFF = 262
Magicians (Draconian)
ARATE : 21 RRATE : 396 DRATE : 126 TOTAL = 12 COSTEFF = 350
Horde (Orc)
ARATE : 633 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 506 TOTAL = 78 COSTEFF = 4270
Settlers (Draconian)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Doom Drakes (Draconian)
ARATE : 613 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 712 TOTAL = 106 COSTEFF = 1818
Air Ship (Draconian)
ARATE : 59 RRATE : 257 DRATE : 712 TOTAL = 54 COSTEFF = 1124
Swordsmen (Dwarf)
ARATE : 158 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 332 TOTAL = 12 COSTEFF = 1748
Halberdiers (Dwarf)
ARATE : 356 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 570 TOTAL = 49 COSTEFF = 3382
Engineers (Dwarf)
ARATE : 33 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 1 COSTEFF = 195
Hammerhands (Dwarf)
ARATE : 712 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 760 TOTAL = 132 COSTEFF = 2459
Steam Cannon (Dwarf)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 297 DRATE : 427 TOTAL = 30 COSTEFF = 1268
Golem (Dwarf)
ARATE : 237 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1029 TOTAL = 59 COSTEFF = 1354
Settlers (Dwarf)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 594 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Spearmen (Gnoll)
ARATE : 237 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 6 COSTEFF = 2796
Swordsmen (Gnoll)
ARATE : 356 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 166 TOTAL = 14 COSTEFF = 1969
Halberdiers (Gnoll)
ARATE : 594 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 380 TOTAL = 55 COSTEFF = 3762
Jackal Riders (Gnoll)
ARATE : 633 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 665 TOTAL = 102 COSTEFF = 2806
Settlers (Gnoll)
ARATE : 12 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 15
Wolf Riders (Gnoll)
ARATE : 396 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 554 TOTAL = 53 COSTEFF = 2742
Spearmen (Halfling)
ARATE : 59 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 211 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 829
Swordsmen (Halfling)
ARATE : 139 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 295 TOTAL = 10 COSTEFF = 1025
Magicians (Halfling)
ARATE : 29 RRATE : 528 DRATE : 147 TOTAL = 19 COSTEFF = 545
Shaman (Halfling)
ARATE : 29 RRATE : 139 DRATE : 147 TOTAL = 6 COSTEFF = 329
Settlers (Halfling)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 264 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Slingers (Halfling)
ARATE : 59 RRATE : 422 DRATE : 211 TOTAL = 24 COSTEFF = 1014
Spearmen (High Elf)
ARATE : 105 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 1032
Swordsmen (High Elf)
ARATE : 211 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 166 TOTAL = 8 COSTEFF = 972
Halberdiers (High Elf)
ARATE : 475 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 380 TOTAL = 44 COSTEFF = 2506
Cavalry (High Elf)
ARATE : 316 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 285 TOTAL = 21 COSTEFF = 1876
Magicians (High Elf)
ARATE : 29 RRATE : 528 DRATE : 110 TOTAL = 14 COSTEFF = 453
Settlers (High Elf)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Longbowmen (High Elf)
ARATE : 44 RRATE : 211 DRATE : 142 TOTAL = 8 COSTEFF = 724
Elven Lords (High Elf)
ARATE : 495 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 506 TOTAL = 61 COSTEFF = 1565
Pegasai (High Elf)
ARATE : 211 RRATE : 139 DRATE : 506 TOTAL = 43 COSTEFF = 1475
Spearmen (High Men)
ARATE : 79 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 2 COSTEFF = 932
Swordsmen (High Men)
ARATE : 158 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 166 TOTAL = 6 COSTEFF = 874
Bowmen (High Men)
ARATE : 33 RRATE : 158 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 5 COSTEFF = 751
Cavalry (High Men)
ARATE : 237 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 285 TOTAL = 16 COSTEFF = 1688
Priests (High Men)
ARATE : 104 RRATE : 237 DRATE : 253 TOTAL = 21 COSTEFF = 862
Magicians (High Men)
ARATE : 33 RRATE : 594 DRATE : 166 TOTAL = 25 COSTEFF = 867
Engineers (High Men)
ARATE : 33 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 97
Settlers (High Men)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Pikemen (High Men)
ARATE : 395 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 380 TOTAL = 36 COSTEFF = 2001
Paladins (High Men)
ARATE : 395 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 712 TOTAL = 68 COSTEFF = 1171
Spearmen (Klackon)
ARATE : 79 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 166 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 1311
Swordsmen (Klackon)
ARATE : 158 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 213 TOTAL = 8 COSTEFF = 1121
Halberdiers (Klackon)
ARATE : 356 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 475 TOTAL = 41 COSTEFF = 2818
Engineers (Klackon)
ARATE : 33 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 194
Settlers (Klackon)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Stag Beetle (Klackon)
ARATE : 346 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 871 TOTAL = 73 COSTEFF = 1883
Spearmen (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 79 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 4 COSTEFF = 1872
Swordsmen (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 158 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 332 TOTAL = 12 COSTEFF = 1748
Halberdiers (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 356 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 570 TOTAL = 49 COSTEFF = 3382
Javelineers (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 356 RRATE : 237 DRATE : 332 TOTAL = 48 COSTEFF = 2625
Shaman (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 52 RRATE : 104 DRATE : 190 TOTAL = 7 COSTEFF = 494
Settlers (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 396 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Dragon Turtle (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 247 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1029 TOTAL = 62 COSTEFF = 2541
Spearmen (Nomad)
ARATE : 79 RRATE : 33 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 1321
Swordsmen (Nomad)
ARATE : 158 RRATE : 79 DRATE : 166 TOTAL = 9 COSTEFF = 1311
Magicians (Troll)
ARATE : 158 RRATE : 396 DRATE : 506 TOTAL = 68 COSTEFF = 1557
Priests (Nomad)
ARATE : 104 RRATE : 237 DRATE : 253 TOTAL = 21 COSTEFF = 862
Magicians (Nomad)
ARATE : 21 RRATE : 396 DRATE : 110 TOTAL = 11 COSTEFF = 382
Settlers (Nomad)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Horsebowmen (Nomad)
ARATE : 158 RRATE : 158 DRATE : 285 TOTAL = 21 COSTEFF = 1801
Pikemen (Nomad)
ARATE : 296 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 285 TOTAL = 20 COSTEFF = 1124
Rangers (Nomad)
ARATE : 316 RRATE : 396 DRATE : 332 TOTAL = 57 COSTEFF = 1575
Griffins (Nomad)
ARATE : 346 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 712 TOTAL = 60 COSTEFF = 1231
Spearmen (Orc)
ARATE : 79 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 2 COSTEFF = 932
Swordsmen (Orc)
ARATE : 158 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 166 TOTAL = 6 COSTEFF = 874
Halberdiers (Orc)
ARATE : 356 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 380 TOTAL = 33 COSTEFF = 2254
Bowmen (Orc)
ARATE : 33 RRATE : 158 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 5 COSTEFF = 751
Cavalry (Orc)
ARATE : 237 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 285 TOTAL = 16 COSTEFF = 1688
Shaman (Orc)
ARATE : 52 RRATE : 104 DRATE : 110 TOTAL = 4 COSTEFF = 343
Magicians (Orc)
ARATE : 21 RRATE : 396 DRATE : 110 TOTAL = 11 COSTEFF = 382
Engineers (Orc)
ARATE : 33 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 97
Settlers (Orc)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Wyvern Riders (Orc)
ARATE : 318 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 712 TOTAL = 55 COSTEFF = 1509
Spearmen (Troll)
ARATE : 158 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 316 TOTAL = 12 COSTEFF = 3328
Swordsmen (Troll)
ARATE : 237 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 443 TOTAL = 25 COSTEFF = 2333
Halberdiers (Troll)
ARATE : 396 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 760 TOTAL = 73 COSTEFF = 3344
Shaman (Troll)
ARATE : 158 RRATE : 104 DRATE : 443 TOTAL = 28 COSTEFF = 1450
Settlers (Troll)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 792 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
War Trolls (Troll)
ARATE : 475 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1013 TOTAL = 117 COSTEFF = 3207
War Mammoths (Troll)
ARATE : 594 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1425 TOTAL = 206 COSTEFF = 4702
Magic Spirit (Neutral)
ARATE : 59 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 316 TOTAL = 4
Hell Hounds (Chaos)
ARATE : 422 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 380 TOTAL = 39
Gargoyles (Chaos)
ARATE : 316 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 823 TOTAL = 63
Fire Giant (Chaos)
ARATE : 422 RRATE : 264 DRATE : 641 TOTAL = 107
Fire Elemental (Chaos)
ARATE : 198 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 316 TOTAL = 15
Chaos Spawn (Chaos)
ARATE : 1324 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1045 TOTAL = 337
Chimera (Chaos)
ARATE : 1478 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1140 TOTAL = 411
Doom Bat (Chaos)
ARATE : 924 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1069 TOTAL = 241
Efreet (Chaos)
ARATE : 429 RRATE : 528 DRATE : 1176 TOTAL = 274
Hydra (Chaos)
ARATE : 3088 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 2851 TOTAL = 2149
Great Drake (Chaos)
ARATE : 3267 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1940 TOTAL = 1547
Skeletons (Death)
ARATE : 211 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 190 TOTAL = 9
Ghouls (Death)
ARATE : 451 RRATE : 379 DRATE : 332 TOTAL = 67
Night Stalker (Death)
ARATE : 432 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 570 TOTAL = 60
Werewolves (Death)
ARATE : 633 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 712 TOTAL = 110
Demon (Death)
ARATE : 316 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 427 TOTAL = 32
Wraiths (Death)
ARATE : 1456 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1267 TOTAL = 450
Shadow Demons (Death)
ARATE : 396 RRATE : 396 DRATE : 633 TOTAL = 122
Death Knights (Death)
ARATE : 1983 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1520 TOTAL = 735
Demon Lord (Death)
ARATE : 1010 RRATE : 614 DRATE : 1940 TOTAL = 769
Zombies (Death)
ARATE : 316 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 498 TOTAL = 38
Unicorns (Life)
ARATE : 528 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1013 TOTAL = 130
Guardian Spirit (Life)
ARATE : 277 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 396 TOTAL = 26
Angel (Life)
ARATE : 618 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1089 TOTAL = 164
Arch Angel (Life)
ARATE : 785 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1774 TOTAL = 339
War Bears (Nature)
ARATE : 396 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 748 TOTAL = 72
Sprites (Nature)
ARATE : 587 RRATE : 587 DRATE : 316 TOTAL = 90
Cockatrices (Nature)
ARATE : 1011 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 997 TOTAL = 246
Great Lizard (Nature)
ARATE : 528 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1306 TOTAL = 168
Giant Spiders (Nature)
ARATE : 662 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 712 TOTAL = 115
Stone Giant (Nature)
ARATE : 594 RRATE : 594 DRATE : 1584 TOTAL = 459
Colossus (Nature)
ARATE : 910 RRATE : 910 DRATE : 2344 TOTAL = 1041
Gorgons (Nature)
ARATE : 1587 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1829 TOTAL = 708
Earth Elemental (Nature)
ARATE : 607 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 950 TOTAL = 140
Behemoth (Nature)
ARATE : 759 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 3207 TOTAL = 594
Great Wyrm (Nature)
ARATE : 1545 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 2138 TOTAL = 806
Floating Island (Sorcery)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 712 TOTAL = 0
Phantom Beast (Sorcery)
ARATE : 844 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 396 TOTAL = 81
Phantom Warriors (Sorcery)
ARATE : 368 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 110 TOTAL = 9
Storm Giant (Sorcery)
ARATE : 536 RRATE : 536 DRATE : 1089 TOTAL = 285
Air Elemental (Sorcery)
ARATE : 428 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 435 TOTAL = 45
Djinn (Sorcery)
ARATE : 633 RRATE : 514 DRATE : 1378 TOTAL = 385
Sky Drake (Sorcery)
ARATE : 1861 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1663 TOTAL = 755
Nagas (Sorcery)
ARATE : 338 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 475 TOTAL = 39
AR = (figs+1)*atk*20 + (figs+1)*thrown*20
RR = (figs+1)*rng*20
DR = HP*5*(Armor+3)
(each applies to hit as the original)
Code: Trireme (None)
ARATE : 475 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 519 TOTAL = 60 COSTEFF = 4108
Galley (None)
ARATE : 554 RRATE : 356 DRATE : 693 TOTAL = 153 COSTEFF = 6306
Catapult (None)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 594 DRATE : 247 TOTAL = 35 COSTEFF = 2095
Warship (None)
ARATE : 633 RRATE : 554 DRATE : 990 TOTAL = 286 COSTEFF = 8393
Spearmen (Barbarian)
ARATE : 415 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 11 COSTEFF = 4897
Swordsmen (Barbarian)
ARATE : 693 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 30 COSTEFF = 4111
Bowmen (Barbarian)
ARATE : 138 RRATE : 415 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 15 COSTEFF = 2175
Cavalry (Barbarian)
ARATE : 792 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 297 TOTAL = 57 COSTEFF = 5880
Shaman (Barbarian)
ARATE : 198 RRATE : 297 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 14 COSTEFF = 1168
Settlers (Barbarian)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Berserkers (Barbarian)
ARATE : 1848 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 534 TOTAL = 240 COSTEFF = 9868
Spearmen (Beastmen)
ARATE : 415 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 24 COSTEFF = 9835
Swordsmen (Beastmen)
ARATE : 554 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 356 TOTAL = 48 COSTEFF = 6574
Halberdiers (Beastmen)
ARATE : 831 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 623 TOTAL = 126 COSTEFF = 8628
Bowmen (Beastmen)
ARATE : 277 RRATE : 415 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 40 COSTEFF = 5466
Priests (Beastmen)
ARATE : 396 RRATE : 495 DRATE : 415 TOTAL = 90 COSTEFF = 3697
Magicians (Beastmen)
ARATE : 198 RRATE : 693 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 51 COSTEFF = 1759
Engineers (Beastmen)
ARATE : 277 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 16 COSTEFF = 2188
Settlers (Beastmen)
ARATE : 39 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 396 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 102
Centaurs (Beastmen)
ARATE : 396 RRATE : 495 DRATE : 316 TOTAL = 68 COSTEFF = 4692
Manticores (Beastmen)
ARATE : 919 RRATE : 285 DRATE : 534 TOTAL = 156 COSTEFF = 4018
Minotaurs (Beastmen)
ARATE : 1188 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 831 TOTAL = 241 COSTEFF = 4936
Spearmen (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 277 RRATE : 138 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 11 COSTEFF = 4080
Swordsmen (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 415 RRATE : 277 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 30 COSTEFF = 3421
Halberdiers (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 693 RRATE : 415 DRATE : 415 TOTAL = 112 COSTEFF = 6386
Cavalry (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 495 RRATE : 297 DRATE : 297 TOTAL = 57 COSTEFF = 4900
Priests (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 297 RRATE : 693 DRATE : 277 TOTAL = 66 COSTEFF = 2285
Settlers (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Nightblades (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 1053 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 623 TOTAL = 160 COSTEFF = 4373
Warlocks (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 99 RRATE : 891 DRATE : 138 TOTAL = 33 COSTEFF = 853
Nightmares (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 792 RRATE : 792 DRATE : 554 TOTAL = 214 COSTEFF = 4387
Spearmen (Draconian)
ARATE : 415 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 148 TOTAL = 14 COSTEFF = 4094
Swordsmen (Draconian)
ARATE : 693 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 207 TOTAL = 35 COSTEFF = 3586
Halberdiers (Draconian)
ARATE : 1108 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 475 TOTAL = 128 COSTEFF = 6578
Bowmen (Draconian)
ARATE : 138 RRATE : 415 DRATE : 148 TOTAL = 19 COSTEFF = 2046
Shaman (Draconian)
ARATE : 198 RRATE : 297 DRATE : 138 TOTAL = 16 COSTEFF = 910
Magicians (Draconian)
ARATE : 99 RRATE : 693 DRATE : 138 TOTAL = 26 COSTEFF = 728
Horde (Orc)
ARATE : 1069 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 554 TOTAL = 144 COSTEFF = 7896
Settlers (Draconian)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 247 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Doom Drakes (Draconian)
ARATE : 1009 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 792 TOTAL = 195 COSTEFF = 3329
Air Ship (Draconian)
ARATE : 198 RRATE : 594 DRATE : 792 TOTAL = 153 COSTEFF = 3136
Swordsmen (Dwarf)
ARATE : 415 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 356 TOTAL = 36 COSTEFF = 4924
Halberdiers (Dwarf)
ARATE : 693 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 623 TOTAL = 105 COSTEFF = 7195
Engineers (Dwarf)
ARATE : 138 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 7 COSTEFF = 817
Hammerhands (Dwarf)
ARATE : 1108 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 831 TOTAL = 224 COSTEFF = 4185
Steam Cannon (Dwarf)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 673 DRATE : 475 TOTAL = 78 COSTEFF = 3196
Golem (Dwarf)
ARATE : 554 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1188 TOTAL = 160 COSTEFF = 3656
Settlers (Dwarf)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 594 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Spearmen (Gnoll)
ARATE : 554 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 15 COSTEFF = 6537
Swordsmen (Gnoll)
ARATE : 693 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 30 COSTEFF = 4111
Halberdiers (Gnoll)
ARATE : 970 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 415 TOTAL = 98 COSTEFF = 6709
Jackal Riders (Gnoll)
ARATE : 1069 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 712 TOTAL = 185 COSTEFF = 5074
Settlers (Gnoll)
ARATE : 79 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 104
Wolf Riders (Gnoll)
ARATE : 693 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 594 TOTAL = 100 COSTEFF = 5145
Spearmen (Halfling)
ARATE : 237 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 211 TOTAL = 12 COSTEFF = 3333
Swordsmen (Halfling)
ARATE : 475 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 316 TOTAL = 36 COSTEFF = 3752
Magicians (Halfling)
ARATE : 132 RRATE : 924 DRATE : 158 TOTAL = 40 COSTEFF = 1112
Shaman (Halfling)
ARATE : 132 RRATE : 396 DRATE : 158 TOTAL = 20 COSTEFF = 1112
Settlers (Halfling)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 264 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Slingers (Halfling)
ARATE : 237 RRATE : 950 DRATE : 211 TOTAL = 61 COSTEFF = 2504
Spearmen (High Elf)
ARATE : 369 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 10 COSTEFF = 3628
Swordsmen (High Elf)
ARATE : 554 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 24 COSTEFF = 2739
Halberdiers (High Elf)
ARATE : 924 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 415 TOTAL = 93 COSTEFF = 5325
Cavalry (High Elf)
ARATE : 660 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 297 TOTAL = 47 COSTEFF = 4083
Magicians (High Elf)
ARATE : 132 RRATE : 924 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 30 COSTEFF = 923
Settlers (High Elf)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Longbowmen (High Elf)
ARATE : 184 RRATE : 554 DRATE : 148 TOTAL = 26 COSTEFF = 2184
Elven Lords (High Elf)
ARATE : 1031 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 554 TOTAL = 139 COSTEFF = 3569
Pegasai (High Elf)
ARATE : 528 RRATE : 396 DRATE : 554 TOTAL = 124 COSTEFF = 4265
Spearmen (High Men)
ARATE : 277 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 7 COSTEFF = 3268
Swordsmen (High Men)
ARATE : 415 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 18 COSTEFF = 2462
Bowmen (High Men)
ARATE : 138 RRATE : 415 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 15 COSTEFF = 2175
Cavalry (High Men)
ARATE : 495 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 297 TOTAL = 35 COSTEFF = 3675
Priests (High Men)
ARATE : 297 RRATE : 495 DRATE : 277 TOTAL = 53 COSTEFF = 2193
Magicians (High Men)
ARATE : 138 RRATE : 970 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 48 COSTEFF = 1643
Engineers (High Men)
ARATE : 138 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 407
Settlers (High Men)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Pikemen (High Men)
ARATE : 890 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 396 TOTAL = 86 COSTEFF = 4699
Paladins (High Men)
ARATE : 742 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 792 TOTAL = 143 COSTEFF = 2448
Spearmen (Klackon)
ARATE : 277 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 12 COSTEFF = 4930
Swordsmen (Klackon)
ARATE : 415 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 24 COSTEFF = 3278
Halberdiers (Klackon)
ARATE : 693 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 534 TOTAL = 90 COSTEFF = 6167
Engineers (Klackon)
ARATE : 138 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 814
Settlers (Klackon)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Stag Beetle (Klackon)
ARATE : 792 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 990 TOTAL = 191 COSTEFF = 4900
Spearmen (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 277 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 16 COSTEFF = 6564
Swordsmen (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 415 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 356 TOTAL = 36 COSTEFF = 4924
Halberdiers (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 693 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 623 TOTAL = 105 COSTEFF = 7195
Javelineers (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 693 RRATE : 554 DRATE : 356 TOTAL = 108 COSTEFF = 5919
Shaman (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 198 RRATE : 297 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 23 COSTEFF = 1633
Settlers (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 396 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Dragon Turtle (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 594 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1188 TOTAL = 172 COSTEFF = 7056
Spearmen (Nomad)
ARATE : 277 RRATE : 138 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 11 COSTEFF = 4897
Swordsmen (Nomad)
ARATE : 415 RRATE : 277 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 30 COSTEFF = 4105
Magicians (Troll)
ARATE : 396 RRATE : 693 DRATE : 396 TOTAL = 105 COSTEFF = 2395
Priests (Nomad)
ARATE : 297 RRATE : 495 DRATE : 277 TOTAL = 53 COSTEFF = 2193
Magicians (Nomad)
ARATE : 99 RRATE : 693 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 22 COSTEFF = 778
Settlers (Nomad)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Horsebowmen (Nomad)
ARATE : 396 RRATE : 396 DRATE : 297 TOTAL = 57 COSTEFF = 4704
Pikemen (Nomad)
ARATE : 692 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 297 TOTAL = 50 COSTEFF = 2740
Rangers (Nomad)
ARATE : 594 RRATE : 693 DRATE : 356 TOTAL = 111 COSTEFF = 3054
Griffins (Nomad)
ARATE : 667 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 792 TOTAL = 128 COSTEFF = 2641
Spearmen (Orc)
ARATE : 277 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 7 COSTEFF = 3268
Swordsmen (Orc)
ARATE : 415 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 18 COSTEFF = 2462
Halberdiers (Orc)
ARATE : 693 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 415 TOTAL = 70 COSTEFF = 4793
Bowmen (Orc)
ARATE : 138 RRATE : 415 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 15 COSTEFF = 2175
Cavalry (Orc)
ARATE : 495 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 297 TOTAL = 35 COSTEFF = 3675
Shaman (Orc)
ARATE : 198 RRATE : 297 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 14 COSTEFF = 1168
Magicians (Orc)
ARATE : 99 RRATE : 693 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 22 COSTEFF = 778
Engineers (Orc)
ARATE : 138 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 407
Settlers (Orc)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Wyvern Riders (Orc)
ARATE : 535 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 792 TOTAL = 103 COSTEFF = 2824
Spearmen (Troll)
ARATE : 396 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 316 TOTAL = 30 COSTEFF = 8342
Swordsmen (Troll)
ARATE : 495 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 475 TOTAL = 57 COSTEFF = 5225
Halberdiers (Troll)
ARATE : 693 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 831 TOTAL = 140 COSTEFF = 6398
Shaman (Troll)
ARATE : 396 RRATE : 297 DRATE : 475 TOTAL = 80 COSTEFF = 4114
Settlers (Troll)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 792 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
War Trolls (Troll)
ARATE : 792 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1108 TOTAL = 214 COSTEFF = 5850
War Mammoths (Troll)
ARATE : 950 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1603 TOTAL = 371 COSTEFF = 8460
Magic Spirit (Neutral)
ARATE : 198 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 346 TOTAL = 16
Hell Hounds (Chaos)
ARATE : 1056 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 396 TOTAL = 102
Gargoyles (Chaos)
ARATE : 660 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 950 TOTAL = 153
Fire Giant (Chaos)
ARATE : 950 RRATE : 633 DRATE : 712 TOTAL = 275
Fire Elemental (Chaos)
ARATE : 475 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 396 TOTAL = 45
Chaos Spawn (Chaos)
ARATE : 1458 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1197 TOTAL = 426
Chimera (Chaos)
ARATE : 2112 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1267 TOTAL = 653
Doom Bat (Chaos)
ARATE : 2112 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1188 TOTAL = 612
Efreet (Chaos)
ARATE : 990 RRATE : 1188 DRATE : 1336 TOTAL = 710
Hydra (Chaos)
ARATE : 3960 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 3118 TOTAL = 3014
Great Drake (Chaos)
ARATE : 5544 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 2252 TOTAL = 3048
Skeletons (Death)
ARATE : 554 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 207 TOTAL = 27
Ghouls (Death)
ARATE : 768 RRATE : 636 DRATE : 356 TOTAL = 122
Night Stalker (Death)
ARATE : 669 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 623 TOTAL = 101
Werewolves (Death)
ARATE : 1108 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 712 TOTAL = 192
Demon (Death)
ARATE : 739 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 475 TOTAL = 85
Wraiths (Death)
ARATE : 2050 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1425 TOTAL = 713
Shadow Demons (Death)
ARATE : 825 RRATE : 825 DRATE : 693 TOTAL = 279
Death Knights (Death)
ARATE : 2875 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1742 TOTAL = 1222
Demon Lord (Death)
ARATE : 2080 RRATE : 1288 DRATE : 2252 TOTAL = 1851
Zombies (Death)
ARATE : 739 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 534 TOTAL = 96
Unicorns (Life)
ARATE : 990 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1108 TOTAL = 267
Guardian Spirit (Life)
ARATE : 554 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 445 TOTAL = 60
Angel (Life)
ARATE : 1402 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1237 TOTAL = 423
Arch Angel (Life)
ARATE : 1755 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 2059 TOTAL = 882
War Bears (Nature)
ARATE : 739 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 831 TOTAL = 149
Sprites (Nature)
ARATE : 316 RRATE : 633 DRATE : 123 TOTAL = 28
Cockatrices (Nature)
ARATE : 1328 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1108 TOTAL = 359
Great Lizard (Nature)
ARATE : 1188 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1485 TOTAL = 430
Giant Spiders (Nature)
ARATE : 1032 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 792 TOTAL = 199
Stone Giant (Nature)
ARATE : 1320 RRATE : 1320 DRATE : 1856 TOTAL = 1196
Colossus (Nature)
ARATE : 1980 RRATE : 1980 DRATE : 2747 TOTAL = 2655
Gorgons (Nature)
ARATE : 2280 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 2079 TOTAL = 1157
Earth Elemental (Nature)
ARATE : 1320 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1039 TOTAL = 334
Behemoth (Nature)
ARATE : 1650 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 3786 TOTAL = 1525
Great Wyrm (Nature)
ARATE : 3227 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 2450 TOTAL = 1930
Floating Island (Sorcery)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 668 TOTAL = 0
Phantom Beast (Sorcery)
ARATE : 1900 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 371 TOTAL = 172
Phantom Warriors (Sorcery)
ARATE : 950 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 103 TOTAL = 23
Storm Giant (Sorcery)
ARATE : 1237 RRATE : 1237 DRATE : 1237 TOTAL = 747
Air Elemental (Sorcery)
ARATE : 990 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 495 TOTAL = 119
Djinn (Sorcery)
ARATE : 1425 RRATE : 1188 DRATE : 1579 TOTAL = 1007
Sky Drake (Sorcery)
ARATE : 3405 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1930 TOTAL = 1604
Nagas (Sorcery)
ARATE : 602 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 519 TOTAL = 76
First thing I notice, the attack rating of everything is higher. Multi figure receives less than single figure, but on average every attack rating is almost double the original. Meanwhile defense ratings are only about 10% better, so the balance between the two is lost.
Units that aren't supposed to have attack power whatsoever, such as barbarian bowmen (1 swords), are now a force that is relevant. (from one sixth of the power of a trireme, they went up to one fourth. A berserker was 33 times more power but now it's only 13 times as powerful.)
I think these numbers are not better than the curent system. Low attack units are overvalued, and attack is higher than defense in general.
However, there is room for improvement. If we keep the "-2" in the formulas, and reduce the "*20" to counter the effect of multiplying with more figures, we get :
Code: Trireme (None)
ARATE : 356 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 519 TOTAL = 45 COSTEFF = 3079
Galley (None)
ARATE : 427 RRATE : 249 DRATE : 693 TOTAL = 114 COSTEFF = 4684
Catapult (None)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 463 DRATE : 247 TOTAL = 27 COSTEFF = 1633
Warship (None)
ARATE : 498 RRATE : 427 DRATE : 990 TOTAL = 223 COSTEFF = 6541
Spearmen (Barbarian)
ARATE : 118 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 1392
Swordsmen (Barbarian)
ARATE : 249 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 10 COSTEFF = 1477
Bowmen (Barbarian)
ARATE : 35 RRATE : 83 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 464
Cavalry (Barbarian)
ARATE : 386 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 297 TOTAL = 27 COSTEFF = 2866
Shaman (Barbarian)
ARATE : 59 RRATE : 59 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 278
Settlers (Barbarian)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Berserkers (Barbarian)
ARATE : 1053 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 534 TOTAL = 137 COSTEFF = 5623
Spearmen (Beastmen)
ARATE : 166 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 9 COSTEFF = 3934
Swordsmen (Beastmen)
ARATE : 249 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 356 TOTAL = 21 COSTEFF = 2954
Halberdiers (Beastmen)
ARATE : 498 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 623 TOTAL = 75 COSTEFF = 5170
Bowmen (Beastmen)
ARATE : 83 RRATE : 83 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 9 COSTEFF = 1311
Priests (Beastmen)
ARATE : 178 RRATE : 267 DRATE : 415 TOTAL = 45 COSTEFF = 1846
Magicians (Beastmen)
ARATE : 59 RRATE : 445 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 29 COSTEFF = 995
Engineers (Beastmen)
ARATE : 83 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 4 COSTEFF = 655
Settlers (Beastmen)
ARATE : 9 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 396 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 23
Centaurs (Beastmen)
ARATE : 178 RRATE : 267 DRATE : 316 TOTAL = 34 COSTEFF = 2343
Manticores (Beastmen)
ARATE : 655 RRATE : 206 DRATE : 534 TOTAL = 112 COSTEFF = 2873
Minotaurs (Beastmen)
ARATE : 891 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 831 TOTAL = 180 COSTEFF = 3702
Spearmen (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 83 RRATE : 35 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 1160
Swordsmen (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 166 RRATE : 83 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 10 COSTEFF = 1231
Halberdiers (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 374 RRATE : 83 DRATE : 415 TOTAL = 46 COSTEFF = 2634
Cavalry (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 267 RRATE : 59 DRATE : 297 TOTAL = 23 COSTEFF = 2017
Priests (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 118 RRATE : 445 DRATE : 277 TOTAL = 38 COSTEFF = 1299
Settlers (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Nightblades (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 734 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 623 TOTAL = 111 COSTEFF = 3048
Warlocks (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 24 RRATE : 623 DRATE : 138 TOTAL = 21 COSTEFF = 558
Nightmares (Dark Elf)
ARATE : 534 RRATE : 534 DRATE : 554 TOTAL = 144 COSTEFF = 2958
Spearmen (Draconian)
ARATE : 118 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 148 TOTAL = 4 COSTEFF = 1164
Swordsmen (Draconian)
ARATE : 249 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 207 TOTAL = 12 COSTEFF = 1288
Halberdiers (Draconian)
ARATE : 540 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 475 TOTAL = 62 COSTEFF = 3206
Bowmen (Draconian)
ARATE : 35 RRATE : 83 DRATE : 148 TOTAL = 4 COSTEFF = 436
Shaman (Draconian)
ARATE : 59 RRATE : 59 DRATE : 138 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 217
Magicians (Draconian)
ARATE : 24 RRATE : 445 DRATE : 138 TOTAL = 15 COSTEFF = 431
Horde (Orc)
ARATE : 641 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 554 TOTAL = 86 COSTEFF = 4734
Settlers (Draconian)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 247 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Doom Drakes (Draconian)
ARATE : 694 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 792 TOTAL = 134 COSTEFF = 2290
Air Ship (Draconian)
ARATE : 106 RRATE : 463 DRATE : 792 TOTAL = 110 COSTEFF = 2253
Swordsmen (Dwarf)
ARATE : 166 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 356 TOTAL = 14 COSTEFF = 1969
Halberdiers (Dwarf)
ARATE : 374 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 623 TOTAL = 56 COSTEFF = 3883
Engineers (Dwarf)
ARATE : 35 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 2 COSTEFF = 207
Hammerhands (Dwarf)
ARATE : 748 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 831 TOTAL = 151 COSTEFF = 2825
Steam Cannon (Dwarf)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 534 DRATE : 475 TOTAL = 61 COSTEFF = 2536
Golem (Dwarf)
ARATE : 427 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1188 TOTAL = 123 COSTEFF = 2818
Settlers (Dwarf)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 594 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Spearmen (Gnoll)
ARATE : 249 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 7 COSTEFF = 2938
Swordsmen (Gnoll)
ARATE : 374 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 16 COSTEFF = 2219
Halberdiers (Gnoll)
ARATE : 623 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 415 TOTAL = 63 COSTEFF = 4309
Jackal Riders (Gnoll)
ARATE : 641 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 712 TOTAL = 111 COSTEFF = 3042
Settlers (Gnoll)
ARATE : 23 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 1 COSTEFF = 30
Wolf Riders (Gnoll)
ARATE : 445 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 594 TOTAL = 64 COSTEFF = 3304
Spearmen (Halfling)
ARATE : 60 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 211 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 844
Swordsmen (Halfling)
ARATE : 142 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 316 TOTAL = 10 COSTEFF = 1121
Magicians (Halfling)
ARATE : 33 RRATE : 594 DRATE : 158 TOTAL = 24 COSTEFF = 660
Shaman (Halfling)
ARATE : 33 RRATE : 79 DRATE : 158 TOTAL = 4 COSTEFF = 235
Settlers (Halfling)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 264 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Slingers (Halfling)
ARATE : 60 RRATE : 427 DRATE : 211 TOTAL = 25 COSTEFF = 1027
Spearmen (High Elf)
ARATE : 110 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 1081
Swordsmen (High Elf)
ARATE : 221 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 9 COSTEFF = 1092
Halberdiers (High Elf)
ARATE : 498 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 415 TOTAL = 50 COSTEFF = 2870
Cavalry (High Elf)
ARATE : 356 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 297 TOTAL = 25 COSTEFF = 2202
Magicians (High Elf)
ARATE : 33 RRATE : 594 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 18 COSTEFF = 548
Settlers (High Elf)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Longbowmen (High Elf)
ARATE : 47 RRATE : 110 DRATE : 148 TOTAL = 5 COSTEFF = 464
Elven Lords (High Elf)
ARATE : 556 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 554 TOTAL = 75 COSTEFF = 1925
Pegasai (High Elf)
ARATE : 237 RRATE : 79 DRATE : 554 TOTAL = 42 COSTEFF = 1458
Spearmen (High Men)
ARATE : 83 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 2 COSTEFF = 979
Swordsmen (High Men)
ARATE : 166 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 7 COSTEFF = 984
Bowmen (High Men)
ARATE : 35 RRATE : 83 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 464
Cavalry (High Men)
ARATE : 267 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 297 TOTAL = 19 COSTEFF = 1982
Priests (High Men)
ARATE : 118 RRATE : 267 DRATE : 277 TOTAL = 26 COSTEFF = 1066
Magicians (High Men)
ARATE : 35 RRATE : 623 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 28 COSTEFF = 976
Engineers (High Men)
ARATE : 35 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 1 COSTEFF = 103
Settlers (High Men)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Pikemen (High Men)
ARATE : 400 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 396 TOTAL = 38 COSTEFF = 2112
Paladins (High Men)
ARATE : 445 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 792 TOTAL = 86 COSTEFF = 1468
Spearmen (Klackon)
ARATE : 83 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 1477
Swordsmen (Klackon)
ARATE : 166 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 9 COSTEFF = 1311
Halberdiers (Klackon)
ARATE : 374 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 534 TOTAL = 48 COSTEFF = 3328
Engineers (Klackon)
ARATE : 35 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 1 COSTEFF = 206
Settlers (Klackon)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Stag Beetle (Klackon)
ARATE : 570 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 990 TOTAL = 137 COSTEFF = 3526
Spearmen (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 83 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 237 TOTAL = 4 COSTEFF = 1967
Swordsmen (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 166 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 356 TOTAL = 14 COSTEFF = 1969
Halberdiers (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 374 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 623 TOTAL = 56 COSTEFF = 3883
Javelineers (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 374 RRATE : 249 DRATE : 356 TOTAL = 54 COSTEFF = 2957
Shaman (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 59 RRATE : 59 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 5 COSTEFF = 389
Settlers (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 396 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Dragon Turtle (Lizardmen)
ARATE : 392 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1188 TOTAL = 113 COSTEFF = 4656
Spearmen (Nomad)
ARATE : 83 RRATE : 35 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 1392
Swordsmen (Nomad)
ARATE : 166 RRATE : 83 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 10 COSTEFF = 1477
Magicians (Troll)
ARATE : 178 RRATE : 445 DRATE : 396 TOTAL = 60 COSTEFF = 1370
Priests (Nomad)
ARATE : 118 RRATE : 267 DRATE : 277 TOTAL = 26 COSTEFF = 1066
Magicians (Nomad)
ARATE : 24 RRATE : 445 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 13 COSTEFF = 461
Settlers (Nomad)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Horsebowmen (Nomad)
ARATE : 178 RRATE : 178 DRATE : 297 TOTAL = 25 COSTEFF = 2114
Pikemen (Nomad)
ARATE : 311 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 297 TOTAL = 22 COSTEFF = 1231
Rangers (Nomad)
ARATE : 356 RRATE : 445 DRATE : 356 TOTAL = 69 COSTEFF = 1901
Griffins (Nomad)
ARATE : 467 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 792 TOTAL = 90 COSTEFF = 1849
Spearmen (Orc)
ARATE : 83 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 2 COSTEFF = 979
Swordsmen (Orc)
ARATE : 166 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 178 TOTAL = 7 COSTEFF = 984
Halberdiers (Orc)
ARATE : 374 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 415 TOTAL = 37 COSTEFF = 2586
Bowmen (Orc)
ARATE : 35 RRATE : 83 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 464
Cavalry (Orc)
ARATE : 267 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 297 TOTAL = 19 COSTEFF = 1982
Shaman (Orc)
ARATE : 59 RRATE : 59 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 3 COSTEFF = 278
Magicians (Orc)
ARATE : 24 RRATE : 445 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 13 COSTEFF = 461
Engineers (Orc)
ARATE : 35 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 118 TOTAL = 1 COSTEFF = 103
Settlers (Orc)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 198 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
Wyvern Riders (Orc)
ARATE : 387 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 792 TOTAL = 74 COSTEFF = 2043
Spearmen (Troll)
ARATE : 178 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 316 TOTAL = 13 COSTEFF = 3749
Swordsmen (Troll)
ARATE : 267 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 475 TOTAL = 30 COSTEFF = 2818
Halberdiers (Troll)
ARATE : 445 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 831 TOTAL = 90 COSTEFF = 4108
Shaman (Troll)
ARATE : 178 RRATE : 59 DRATE : 475 TOTAL = 27 COSTEFF = 1407
Settlers (Troll)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 792 TOTAL = 0 COSTEFF = 0
War Trolls (Troll)
ARATE : 534 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1108 TOTAL = 144 COSTEFF = 3944
War Mammoths (Troll)
ARATE : 712 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1603 TOTAL = 278 COSTEFF = 6340
Magic Spirit (Neutral)
ARATE : 106 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 346 TOTAL = 8
Hell Hounds (Chaos)
ARATE : 475 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 396 TOTAL = 45
Gargoyles (Chaos)
ARATE : 356 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 950 TOTAL = 82
Fire Giant (Chaos)
ARATE : 760 RRATE : 475 DRATE : 712 TOTAL = 214
Fire Elemental (Chaos)
ARATE : 356 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 396 TOTAL = 34
Chaos Spawn (Chaos)
ARATE : 1341 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1197 TOTAL = 391
Chimera (Chaos)
ARATE : 1425 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1267 TOTAL = 440
Doom Bat (Chaos)
ARATE : 1662 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1188 TOTAL = 482
Efreet (Chaos)
ARATE : 772 RRATE : 950 DRATE : 1336 TOTAL = 561
Hydra (Chaos)
ARATE : 2613 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 3118 TOTAL = 1989
Great Drake (Chaos)
ARATE : 4704 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 2252 TOTAL = 2586
Skeletons (Death)
ARATE : 221 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 207 TOTAL = 11
Ghouls (Death)
ARATE : 477 RRATE : 319 DRATE : 356 TOTAL = 69
Night Stalker (Death)
ARATE : 537 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 623 TOTAL = 81
Werewolves (Death)
ARATE : 665 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 712 TOTAL = 115
Demon (Death)
ARATE : 570 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 475 TOTAL = 66
Wraiths (Death)
ARATE : 1588 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1425 TOTAL = 552
Shadow Demons (Death)
ARATE : 445 RRATE : 445 DRATE : 693 TOTAL = 150
Death Knights (Death)
ARATE : 2181 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1742 TOTAL = 927
Demon Lord (Death)
ARATE : 1739 RRATE : 1026 DRATE : 2252 TOTAL = 1520
Zombies (Death)
ARATE : 332 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 534 TOTAL = 43
Unicorns (Life)
ARATE : 594 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1108 TOTAL = 160
Guardian Spirit (Life)
ARATE : 356 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 445 TOTAL = 38
Angel (Life)
ARATE : 1113 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1237 TOTAL = 336
Arch Angel (Life)
ARATE : 1413 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 2059 TOTAL = 710
War Bears (Nature)
ARATE : 475 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 831 TOTAL = 96
Sprites (Nature)
ARATE : 95 RRATE : 285 DRATE : 123 TOTAL = 11
Cockatrices (Nature)
ARATE : 1037 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1108 TOTAL = 280
Great Lizard (Nature)
ARATE : 950 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1485 TOTAL = 344
Giant Spiders (Nature)
ARATE : 715 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 792 TOTAL = 138
Stone Giant (Nature)
ARATE : 1069 RRATE : 1069 DRATE : 1856 TOTAL = 968
Colossus (Nature)
ARATE : 1639 RRATE : 1639 DRATE : 2747 TOTAL = 2198
Gorgons (Nature)
ARATE : 1844 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 2079 TOTAL = 935
Earth Elemental (Nature)
ARATE : 1092 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1039 TOTAL = 276
Behemoth (Nature)
ARATE : 1366 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 3786 TOTAL = 1262
Great Wyrm (Nature)
ARATE : 2732 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 2450 TOTAL = 1634
Floating Island (Sorcery)
ARATE : 0 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 668 TOTAL = 0
Phantom Beast (Sorcery)
ARATE : 1520 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 371 TOTAL = 137
Phantom Warriors (Sorcery)
ARATE : 380 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 103 TOTAL = 9
Storm Giant (Sorcery)
ARATE : 965 RRATE : 965 DRATE : 1237 TOTAL = 582
Air Elemental (Sorcery)
ARATE : 771 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 495 TOTAL = 93
Djinn (Sorcery)
ARATE : 1140 RRATE : 926 DRATE : 1579 TOTAL = 796
Sky Drake (Sorcery)
ARATE : 2779 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 1930 TOTAL = 1309
Nagas (Sorcery)
ARATE : 370 RRATE : 0 DRATE : 519 TOTAL = 46
Not bad but I think single figure units are overrated now.
How about something in between : (figures+0.5)... which is (figures*2+1)/2.
|
