WW26: The Masquerade [Game Thread]

[Sir Percival]

Also Sir Percival

good case. would case again.

[Short Richard]

BRick being mean enough to make a friendly neighbor be a wolf feels farfetched enough to be ruled out. My first impression was that Saul was obviously a wolf and that I couldn't believe Saul got someone mislynched and got away with it. I've have been getting village reads on him, and have been warming up to the Fool idea...

Definitely getting an uneasy feeling from Muriel's posts. I still can't wrap my head around her argument with Sister Mary.

[Young Will]

I'm waiting for Saul to pipe up with his seer results before I vote.



*AHEM*

[Doctor Saul]

I'm waiting for Saul to pipe up with his seer results before I vote.



*AHEM*

Sorry, I did not think it was useful anymore since it is not 100% sure to me now. And I do not trust it either because I think someone may have messed with it again. But I scanned Know-Nothing Jon and it said he was a wolf.

I want to read more before I vote. I do not trust my result to vote for Jon based only on that.

[Sir Percival]

considering jon i had village tell on, lends credibility to my theory that ur getting opposite results to true alignment.

[Rob The Filch]

Saul You are either a fool with a random alignment scan or an insane seer getting exact opposite results... Or you are a wolf.


I would vote Muriel but I hate short Richards most recent vote on Muriel. He says he doesn't understand the argument with sister Mary so that's his reason for voting for her. That was how long ago? And what about her most recent thoughts? It's too lazy and my scum dar is going crazy on him. short Richard

Additionally Saul's posts have been progressively scummier...

[Agnes The Orphan]

Hmm, supports the opposite results idea.
Definitely Muriel today.

Agree that short Richards last is bad, but not nearly so much as all of Muriels last night.

[Young Will]

I'm waiting for Saul to pipe up with his seer results before I vote.



*AHEM*

Sorry, I did not think it was useful anymore since it is not 100% sure to me now. And I do not trust it either because I think someone may have messed with it again. But I scanned Know-Nothing Jon and it said he was a wolf.

I want to read more before I vote. I do not trust my result to vote for Jon based only on that.

yes, but that doesnt mean you can't get information.

if muriel is a wolf, as seems very likely, then we can confirm you as a fool, which would confirm Jon and probably you as well as village.


short richard may very well be a wolf as well, but his lynch gives us much less information.

[Sir Percival]

had thought while on train so can't reread yet but want to get it down so dont forget. saul was not night target. therefore scum thought he wasnt threat. therefore scum either believed they would continue to prevent correct scan, they believed saul to receive random result, or saul is scum. i want to rule out first option because i can't see framer as guessing who Saul target 2 night in row, and KNJ i lean town on. 3rd option despite Saul strange play last night and so far today seems unlikely because as muriel mentioned saul day 2 play backs up Saul having had scan result. so that leaves believed saul to have random result. which players suggested that Saul got random result? that's what i look into when on pc again.

[Know-Nothing Jon]

BRick being mean enough to make a friendly neighbor be a wolf feels farfetched enough to be ruled out. My first impression was that Saul was obviously a wolf and that I couldn't believe Saul got someone mislynched and got away with it. I've have been getting village reads on him, and have been warming up to the Fool idea...

Definitely getting an uneasy feeling from Muriel's posts. I still can't wrap my head around her argument with Sister Mary.

I agree very much with Rob, this is a really scummy post. What does that last sentence even mean? It contains nothing that even approaches an argument for Muriel's guilt, and as far as I can tell it's not a reference to anything he's said before, even though it's phrased like that. I'm getting Easy Sarah flashbacks from this post.

Saul's result does lend credence to the insane seer theory. So my mind has to agree that there's now a decent amount of evidence to implicate him, but my gut is not completely on board yet. I guess I'll see how well Muriel defends before I decide.