|
Is that character a variant? (I just love getting asked that in channel.) - Charis |
|
New FFH2 PBEM?
|
(May 6th, 2015, 18:47)Northstar1989 Wrote: Oh wait- that timestamp was when Old Lion sent OUT the save. You can send it out. But he can play it only if Tasunke hasn't started the firat save yet
May 6th, 2015, 19:16
(This post was last modified: May 6th, 2015, 19:19 by Northstar1989.)
 (May 6th, 2015, 19:04)Kragroth Wrote:(May 6th, 2015, 18:47)Northstar1989 Wrote: Oh wait- that timestamp was when Old Lion sent OUT the save. Once again, you don't make the rules for everyone else Kragroth... If this is some kind of democracy then there would need to be a note for an official decision- but every principle of common courtesy and decency says we should just replay the save here without needing to hold a vote... Old Lion appears to have not followed my instructions for Turn 30 at all. The mistake that was due to botched instructions on my part (that I could have easily caught if I had been playing it myself) was on Turn 29. Tasunke needs to re-play Turn 31 even if he already played it. The mistakes Old Lion appeared to make (things like leaving a freshly-built unit idle when I told him where it needed to go) were major and simply not acceptable losses when I got the replay out a mere 4 hours later (we'll still be making 1-2 turns today...) Regards, Northstar
Today I hadn't yet played or sent the save, and therefore I was able, today, to play Northstar's save. However had I already played it and sent it on to Sarumon I would not have replayed it ... (unless, at best, the save was still with Sarumon)
(May 6th, 2015, 19:55)Ellimist Wrote: I concur with Kragoth and Tasunke. Concur? There's nothing to concur to- no question. Tasunke already said he got my save before he played his turn, and used it instead of the (possibly botched- I have no *definitive* confirmation he did what I think he did based on his overly-short turn report) one played by Old Lion... Regards, Northstar (May 6th, 2015, 19:51)Tasunke Wrote: Today I hadn't yet played or sent the save, and therefore I was able, today, to play Northstar's save. However had I already played it and sent it on to Sarumon I would not have replayed it ... (unless, at best, the save was still with Sarumon) Also, if the save was still with Saruman (and he hadn't played it yet), there would have been no reason not to replay. It wouldn't have caused any delay (as Saruman wouldn't have played yet), and you would have just had to replay your turn *exactly* as before... (since nothing I fixed would have directly affected you yet) Regards, Northstar (May 6th, 2015, 20:08)Northstar1989 Wrote: Concur? There's nothing to concur to- no question. Tasunke already said he got my save before he played his turn, and used it instead of the (possibly botched- I have no *definitive* confirmation he did what I think he did based on his overly-short turn report) one played by Old Lion... I meant that I agreed with both of these statements: (May 6th, 2015, 19:04)Kragroth Wrote: You can send it out. But he can play it only if Tasunke hasn't started the first save yet (May 6th, 2015, 19:51)Tasunke Wrote: However had I already played it and sent it on to Sarumon I would not have replayed it ... Specifically in response to this statement: (May 6th, 2015, 19:16)Northstar1989 Wrote: Once again, you don't make the rules for everyone else Kragroth... I was at work when I posted earlier, and didn't have time for a more detailed comment.
Active in:
FFH-20: Jonas Endain of the Clan of Embers EITB Pitboss 1: Clan/Elohim/Calabim with Mardoc and Thoth |
